Wadcutter

IL

Senior Member

Joined: 05/25/2004

View Profile

|
JIMNLIN wrote:
571 FMCSA regs on door tag info does apply just as federal motor vehicle safety standards apply part 49 sect 567.4 thats says that door tag is a legal document. I never said we need a commercial license for our RVs. What those fed laws I just mention says is your mattress tag theory is just that, your theory. Door tag info is a legal document per those fed regs I mentioned above. Your saying they don't apply ?? Your kiddin' , right ??
How your/my state enforces those regs is why I keep saying , check with your state for their input on how thay enforce those FMCSA regs.
JIM
Once more - you're mixing apples and oranges and coming up with roast beef. No where does anything in FMCSA refers to the door tag. Sorry, but you're reading one thing and thinking it means something else. Again, a typical case of knowing a little bit about something and thinking it makes you an expert.
BTW, I don't need to check with my state. I taught MCS. I was on several advisory committees with the feds and other states. I worked with it for a lot of years. MCS doesn't apply to what you are trying to make it sound.
Nothing, including FMCSA, requires the federal sticker. Sorry, but all your quotes don't say that it does.
Besides, FMCSA doesn't have any bearing whatsoever on the topic.
Camped in every state
|
BertP

Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Senior Member

Joined: 11/07/2003

View Profile

|
Section 110 paragraph S4.3 says that the placard (or door tag) is required and specifies what must be on it.
Bert
|
Wadcutter

IL

Senior Member

Joined: 05/25/2004

View Profile

|
BertP wrote: Section 110 paragraph S4.3 says that the placard (or door tag) is required and specifies what must be on it.
Bert
Once again you've proven my point that you don't understand what you are reading. It's talking about the "manufacturer", ie the builder.
Thanks for helping me prove my point about knowing a little and not understanding.
|
BertP

Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Senior Member

Joined: 11/07/2003

View Profile

|
wadcutter wrote: No where does anything in FMCSA refers to the door tag.
Bert wrote: Section 110 paragraph S4.3 says that the placard (or door tag) is required and specifies what must be on it.
wadcutter wrote: Once again you've proven my point that you don't understand what you are reading. It's talking about the "manufacturer", ie the builder.
Thanks for helping me prove my point about knowing a little and not understanding.
Thanks for clearing that up. I don't know what I was thinking.
Bert
PS For the record, 571.110 S4.3 states:
S4.3 Placard. Each vehicle, except for a trailer or incomplete vehicle, shall show the information specified in S4.3 (a) through (g), and may show, at the manufacturer's option, the information specified in S4.3 (h) and (i), on a placard permanently affixed to the driver's side B-pillar. In each vehicle without a driver's side B-pillar and with two doors on the driver's side of the vehicle opening in opposite directions, the placard shall be affixed on the forward edge of the rear side door. If the above locations do not permit the affixing of a placard that is legible, visible and prominent, the placard shall be permanently affixed to the rear edge of the driver's side door. If this location does not permit the affixing of a placard that is legible, visible and prominent, the placard shall be affixed to the inward facing surface of the vehicle next to the driver's seating position. This information shall be in the English language and conform in color and format, not including the border surrounding the entire placard, as shown in the example set forth in Figure 1 in this standard. At the manufacturer's option, the information specified in S4.3 (c), (d), and, as appropriate, (h) and (i) may be shown, alternatively to being shown on the placard, on a tire inflation pressure label which must conform in color and format, not including the border surrounding the entire label, as shown in the example set forth in Figure 2 in this standard. The label shall be permanently affixed and proximate to the placard required by this paragraph. The information specified in S4.3 (e) shall be shown on both the vehicle placard and on the tire inflation pressure label (if such a label is affixed to provide the information specified in S4.3 (c), (d), and, as appropriate, (h) and (i)) may be shown in the format and color scheme set forth in Figures 1 and 2.
|
Wadcutter

IL

Senior Member

Joined: 05/25/2004

View Profile

|
Once again, none of that matters. FMCSA doesn't apply to you pulling your TT, 5er, or driving your Class A. You aren't a motor carrier so forget there is even such a thing as FMCSA. It doesn't apply. If you think FMCSA applies then get your medical card and start filling out your log book everytime you get behind the wheel. But make sure you fill it out correctly or you'll be fined and parked out of service for at least 8 hours.
|
|
JIMNLIN

Oklahoma

Senior Member

Joined: 09/14/2003

View Profile

|
Wadcutter wrote: Once again, none of that matters. FMCSA doesn't apply to you pulling your TT, 5er, or driving your Class A. You aren't a motor carrier so forget there is even such a thing as FMCSA. It doesn't apply. If you think FMCSA applies then get your medical card and start filling out your log book everytime you get behind the wheel. But make sure you fill it out correctly or you'll be fined and parked out of service for at least 8 hours. ![doh [emoticon]](http://www.coastresorts.com/sharedcontent/cfb/images/doh.gif)
thats been covered and mentioned many times that as RVers we are not required to be commercially licensed BUT the OP asked for fed regs (FMCSA) on door tag placards (door tag) about GVWR/GAWR which is clearly used with these trucks for commercial registration per FMCSA. Looking at federal motor vehicle safety standard (FMVSS) 49 cfr part 571.110 and .120 clearly says GVWR/GAWR will be on the door placard (door tag} for under 10000 GVWR/over 10000 lb GVWR. The door tag (placard} is a legal fed document according to FMVSS cfr 49 part 567.4 if any one is interested in reading anything legal pertaining to door tag and GVAR/GAWR rating on that tag for that vehicle. So to answer the OP question about the door tag being a legal document its allLots of reading if anyones interested. If anyones interested go to your state motor vehicle web and do a search on how your state interpets the info on our LDT trucks door tag.
JIM
"good judgment comes from experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgment" ............ Will Rogers
'03 2500 QC Dodge/Cummins HO 3.73 6 speed manual Jacobs Westach
'97 Park Avanue 28' 5er 11200 two slides
|
jmramiller

Dallas

Senior Member

Joined: 01/24/2006

View Profile

|
JIMNLIN wrote: Wadcutter wrote: Once again, none of that matters. FMCSA doesn't apply to you pulling your TT, 5er, or driving your Class A. You aren't a motor carrier so forget there is even such a thing as FMCSA. It doesn't apply. If you think FMCSA applies then get your medical card and start filling out your log book everytime you get behind the wheel. But make sure you fill it out correctly or you'll be fined and parked out of service for at least 8 hours. ![doh [emoticon]](http://www.coastresorts.com/sharedcontent/cfb/images/doh.gif)
thats been covered and mentioned many times that as RVers we are not required to be commercially licensed BUT the OP asked for fed regs (FMCSA) on door tag placards (door tag) about GVWR/GAWR which is clearly used with these trucks for commercial registration per FMCSA. Looking at federal motor vehicle safety standard (FMVSS) 49 cfr part 571.110 and .120 clearly says GVWR/GAWR will be on the door placard (door tag} for under 10000 GVWR/over 10000 lb GVWR. The door tag (placard} is a legal fed document according to FMVSS cfr 49 part 567.4 if any one is interested in reading anything legal pertaining to door tag and GVAR/GAWR rating on that tag for that vehicle. So to answer the OP question about the door tag being a legal document its allLots of reading if anyones interested. If anyones interested go to your state motor vehicle web and do a search on how your state interpets the info on our LDT trucks door tag.
JIM
As this is a RV forum I in no way intended the OP to be about commercial towing. I created this thread in direct response to your multitude of posts suggesting to others that if they exceed the axle ratings posted on the door sticker they are in violation of both federal and OK law per FMCSA. You have repeatedly stated that OK uses these regs for both commercial and non commercial vehicles suggesting that non commercial TV's are legally bound by the door sticker. You have repeatedly stated that if you are pulling an RV and you get weighed for any reason in OK and over the door sticker axke weights you will be cited. After reading both the FMCSA and the OK regs there is not a single instance where the RAWR on the door sticker is legally binding. The regs do not even limit the steering axle to the door sticker ratings unless the state writes it in their own codes which the FMCSA allows but does not mandate. I challange you to prove otherwise.
As far as the sticker being required by law...this is intended to protect the consumer from fraudulant claims by the manufacturer. No where in the regs that require the sticker does it require the consumer to abide by these numbers. The comparison of a mattress tag is a very good one. In fact the mattress tag clearly states that it is unlawful for the sticker to be removed by anyone other than the end user. My door sticker doesn't say anywhere that it can not be removed.
* This post was
edited 11/28/07 04:31pm by jmramiller *
2006 2500HD CC SB 4X4 Duramax/Allison
Prodigy/16K Reese/265E Tires/Bilstein Shocks
RM Active Suspension/RDS 60gal Toolbox combo
2008 Big Country 3490BHS by Heartland
|
JIMNLIN

Oklahoma

Senior Member

Joined: 09/14/2003

View Profile

|
jmramiller wrote: (snip)
As this is a RV forum I in no way intended the OP to be about commercial towing. I created this thread in direct response to your multitude of posts suggesting to others that if they exceed the axle ratings posted on the door sticker they are in violation of both federal and OK law per FMCSA. You have repeatedly stated that OK uses these regs for both commercial and non commercial vehicles suggesting that non commercial TV's are legally bound by the door sticker. You have repeatedly stated that if you are pulling an RV and you get weighed for any reason in OK and over the door sticker axke weights you will be cited. After reading both the FMCSA and the OK regs there is not a single instance where the RAWR on the door sticker is legally binding. The regs do not even limit the steering axle to the door sticker ratings unless the state writes it in their own codes which the FMCSA allows but does not mandate. I challange you to prove otherwise.
As far as the sticker being required by law...this is intended to protect the consumer from fraudulant claims by the manufacturer. No where in the regs that require the sticker does it require the consumer to abide by these numbers. The comparison of a mattress tag is a very good one. In fact the mattress tag clearly states that it is unlawful for the sticker to be removed by anyone other than the end user. My door sticker doesn't say anywhere that it can not be removed.
you betcha' I have stated how my state enforces door tag axle weights as that is how we balance our loads per FMCSA commercial combined hauling. Any hotshoter/commercial hauler will tell you that. See my replies above for FMCSA regs. Your interpetation of cfr 49 part 567.4 as a matteress tag is yout opinion. No where does it say its just a tag for fradulent claims (disclaimer). Quite the contary. Fmcsa 571.110 is 12 pages long and states how GAWR/tire capacity/GVWR are tied and the placard with that info and the placard are a statutary requirement. That also is a state/fed requirement for a usdot number application and for a commercial combined tag for 26000 lb and above.
No where have I repeatedly said we can be pulled over and cited for being over axle weights. Quite the opposite. Just as those two officer said that RVs are a low priority. What I have said is my state uses those door tag axle weights for commercial (FMCSA) and non commercial which includes axle weights right off the door tag. Your interpetation of my states regs we enforce is quite different that my state dot and OHP officers verbal info as they gave. As I said earlier guess whos interpetation I'll use. How about some documentation to back up your claims. You can't do it. Thats why I went to my state to get their interpetation.
It looks to me as your not interested in finding any legalities as you seem to have a agenda just to prove someone wrong. The only way to prove I'm wrong is show folks a reg that states your claim/opinion.
Those FMCSA 571 regs and FMVSS 571 regs and FMVSS 567.4 and .5 aren't just for looks or simply as a disclaimer but are statutory laws pertaining to door tag (placard) info.
Just a point when your looking at fed regs on the web is sometime its a shortened version. Also look at disclaimer or new law clickies when your in FMCSA regs.
|
JIMNLIN

Oklahoma

Senior Member

Joined: 09/14/2003

View Profile

|
Bert
571.110 S2.2.1 says "except as noted in S4.2.2.2, the sum of the maximum load ratings of the tires fited to an axle shall not be less than the GAWR of the axle system as specified on the vehicles certification required by 49 CFR part 567 (FMVSS placard reg). If the certification label shows more than one GAWR for the axle system, the sum shall be not less than the GAWR corresponding to the size designation of the tires fitted to the axle".
This ties tires capacity and GAWR. Also see S4.3.3
See 571.3 for GAWR definitions.
NHTSA regs 571.110 refere to GAWR and tires capacities.
How FMCSA/FMVSS/NHTSA regs are interpeted by the states can be argued from now on unless one goes to their state for guidense on how they interpet and enforce those regs.
Does your province/Canada even recognize any of the above regulatories ??
JIM
|
BertP

Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Senior Member

Joined: 11/07/2003

View Profile

|
I saw that. I had been wondering where the legislation was that statedd that you were not permitted to exceed the capacity rating of your tires. I kew it was a bad idea to exceed the tire capacity but you can't be ticketed for having a bad idea.
No, neither Canada nor Alberta recognize any of those regulatories. What I was hoping for was to find the legislation in the US that addressed these issues so I could see the legal language used. Since I have not been able to find the equivalent legislation here, I figured that either it doesn't exist (definate possibility) or I was searching using the wrong terminology (also a definate possibility).
Bert
|
|