Open Roads Forum |
Print | Close |
Topic: Curt vs B&W |
Posted By: Madfun119
on 08/20/17 06:10pm
|
I have a F350 Super Duty with the puck system. Seeing great reviews for both. Curt appears considerably less expensive.
|
Posted By: MFL
on 08/20/17 07:13pm
|
You will not be disappointed, by spending a little more for the 3300! Jerry ![]() |
Posted By: azdryheat
on 08/20/17 07:24pm
|
Why? Why is the 3300 better?
2013 Chevy 3500HD CC dually 2014 Voltage 3600 toy hauler 2019 RZR 1000XP TRE ![]() |
Posted By: B.O. Plenty
on 08/20/17 07:41pm
|
Curt uses foreign made parts assembled in the U.S. Decent unit a little hard to operate at times. B&W is all made in America with all American raw materials. Easiest hitch I have ever hitched or unhitched. Very smooth, positive operation. Shop online and there isn't much price difference. You will get what you pay for. B.O. Former Ram/Cummins owner 2015 Silverado 3500 D/A DRW Yup I'm a fanboy! 2016 Cedar Creek 36CKTS |
Posted By: dfletch
on 08/20/17 07:49pm
|
I put a Curt Q20 in my TV and have had no problems.
David & Teresa 2017 Cedar Creek Silverback 37 MBH 2017 Silverado 3500HD Duramax 4X4 Crewcab longbed dully ![]() |
Posted By: guidry
on 08/20/17 08:14pm
|
Another vote for BW!
|
Posted By: Showme 5vr
on 08/20/17 08:48pm
|
No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it!
Steve & Judy 2023 RAM 3500 6.7L Cummins HO Crew Cab LWB, 2017 Grand Design Reflections 337RLS Lifetime Good Sam Member ![]() |
Posted By: ChuckV1
on 08/20/17 09:35pm
|
I have a Curt 16k an love it ![]() |
Posted By: tinner12002
on 08/21/17 04:17am
|
Showme 5vr wrote: ![]() No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it! X2 2015 Ram 3500/DRW/Aisin/auto/Max tow/4.10s,Cummins, stock Laramie Limited--Silver Tequila Sunrise 2012 Ultra Classic Limited 2018 Raptor 428SP |
Posted By: Toolguy5
on 08/21/17 04:42am
|
I have no experience with Curt. I do have a B&W companion slider. I love it. If your undecided I would physically look at both and go with the one you feel is best. Good luck and Happy Trails Dan Dan & Patty Miss Pickles the Pomeranian Princess Rainbow Bridge 8/8/2023 2020 GMC 3500 Sierra Denali 6.6 Duramax / Allison tranny 2021 Jayco Eagle 319MLOK BWRVK 3710 companion Maddy the Pampered Pom @ Rainbow Bridge 12-3-2013 |
Posted By: Arcamper
on 08/21/17 07:40am
|
tinner12002 wrote: ![]() Showme 5vr wrote: ![]() No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it! X2 X3 2016 Montana 3100RL Legacy(LT's,Joy Rider 2's,disc brakes) 2014 Ram 3500 DRW Laramie Cummins/Aisin 14,000 GVWR 2014 Ford Expedition Limited, HD tow pkg 2016 Honda Civic EX-T 1999 Stingray 240LS 1994 Chevy 1500 5.7 PU 2018 John Deere 1025R B&W RVK3600 Hitch ![]() |
Posted By: Hammerboy
on 08/21/17 08:45am
|
Arcamper wrote: ![]() tinner12002 wrote: ![]() Showme 5vr wrote: ![]() No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it! X2 X3 X4 2019 Chevy crew LTZ 2500 HD Duramax 2017 Wildcat 29rlx fifth wheel |
Posted By: Travlingman
on 08/21/17 10:09am
|
Had a B&W in my last truck, went with a Curt Q25 in my new F-350. Have no issues at all. Like that it has a higher capacity than the B&W with the Ford puck system, it is SAE certified, and the fully articulating head. Had no issues with my B&W.
2017 F-350 King Ranch DRW 2014 Landmark Savannah(sold) 2022 DRV Mobile Suite 40KSSB4 |
Posted By: Cummins12V98
on 08/21/17 10:11am
|
B.O. Plenty wrote: ![]() Curt uses foreign made parts assembled in the U.S. Decent unit a little hard to operate at times. B&W is all made in America with all American raw materials. Easiest hitch I have ever hitched or unhitched. Very smooth, positive operation. Shop online and there isn't much price difference. You will get what you pay for. B.O. CURT is "MADE" in CHINA. Just compare them side by side! 2015 RAM LongHorn 3500 Dually CrewCab 4X4 CUMMINS/AISIN RearAir 385HP/865TQ 4:10's 37,800# GCVWR "Towing Beast" "HeavyWeight" B&W RVK3600 2016 MobileSuites 39TKSB3 highly "Elited" In the stable 2007.5 Mobile Suites 36 SB3 29,000# Combined SOLD |
Posted By: Cummins12V98
on 08/21/17 10:20am
|
Oh I forgot to mention the CURT head with it's pivot point several inches below the kingpin connection can cause CHUCKING. Documented here by several people. B&W, simple solid latching with a machined 1" thick jaw. CURT flimsy lock color coding with 1/2" thick jaws. B&W 4 - 1/2" grade 8 bolts each side holding head supports, Curt two questionable grade bolts each side holding head. Look at the attachment areas to the bed. B&W is simply a Superior product with no negatives, can't say the same about Curt. ![]() ![]() * This post was edited 08/21/17 11:51am by Cummins12V98 * |
Posted By: Greene728
on 08/21/17 11:27am
|
Nothing necessarily wrong with a Curt as they are "sufficient". When compared to a B&W they are inferior. Just not as well made period. 2011 Crossroads Cruiser 29BHS ( Traded ) 2017 Grand Design 303RLS ( Sold ) Currently camperless ( Just taking a break ) 2016 Chevy Silverado 2500 4x4 6.0 and 4:10’s Me and the wife and our two daughters. Life's good! |
Posted By: Helmsey
on 08/21/17 11:31am
|
I love my B&W, I can't wait to get the Pullrite out of my (new to me) truck and get the Companion back in. One thing that sold me with the B&W is the customer service. I had a question about a part and when I called them an actual person answered the phone. I was transferred one time to a person that was able to answer my question and then explain why it was doing what I was concerned with. KK4PFX 2015 Chevy 3500HD LTZ Dually 2013 Sandpiper 365SAQ ![]() |
Posted By: laknox
on 08/21/17 11:42am
|
One more vote for B&W. Both the products and the company. Needed new u-bolts for my old-style Companion, called B&W and they had a set overnighted to me. After about 10 minutes, I realized that I had =already= called them about 2 months before and tried to cancel my order. They told me to just keep the 2nd set because I'll need them...eventually. ![]() Lyle 2022 GMC Sierra 3500 HD Denali Crew Cab 4x4 Duramax B&W OEM Companion & Gooseneck Kit 2017 KZ Durango 1500 D277RLT 1936 John Deere Model A International Flying Farmers 64 Year Member |
Posted By: Brisk
on 08/21/17 11:57am
|
B&W hands down
Brent('85) & Lindsay('86) DDs('08 &'11) '14 RAM Laramie 3500SRW CCLB Cummins/4x4/68RFE -B&W Turnover Ball/Anderson Ultimate Aluminum Toyhauler-'06 Forest River Sierra Sport F32 2001 Malibu Sunsetter VLX Wakeboat ![]() |
Posted By: bama2
on 08/21/17 03:13pm
|
b & w all the way
|
Posted By: Tango, AE7UI
on 08/21/17 03:41pm
|
I have lost count of the plus reviews for the B&W. I have the Companion with out the pucks. Add mine to the plus column. Have used it for the past 9 years and won't even consider any other brand. 2007 Tango 2660RKS Fifth Wheel, 2006 Chevy D/A 3500 with service body, |
Posted By: reppoc12
on 08/21/17 04:00pm
|
This is my experience. I have a Ram with the puck system. Had a Curt Q24 and had problems a number of times both hithching and unhitching. I would always get it but got tired of playing with it to get it just right. Got a B&W 3600 and it hitches and unhitches first time every time.
|
Posted By: RCMAN46
on 08/21/17 04:08pm
|
I do not believe I have seen a Curt do this.![]() |
Posted By: laknox
on 08/21/17 04:30pm
|
RCMAN46 wrote: ![]() I do not believe I have seen a Curt do this. ![]() In a rollover, all bets are off. Lyle |
Posted By: JIMNLIN
on 08/22/17 05:49am
|
Curt vs B&W hitch ?? Same as Ford vs Chevy. Both are top hitches for light duty work such as pulling a rv. Hitch brand/truck brand comments are alway amusing from those who have never owned the product or I had one back in the day. Keep in mind popular doesn't always = best bang for the bucks ie; ST tires being popular. I would choose the one that best suits your needs. "good judgment comes from experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgment" ............ Will Rogers '03 2500 QC Dodge/Cummins HO 3.73 6 speed manual Jacobs Westach '97 Park Avanue 28' 5er 11200 two slides |
Posted By: Nlambert182
on 08/22/17 10:06am
|
I have the B&W Companion slider (3405) in my Ram 2500 and love it. Very easy and quick to hook up and there is never any doubt that there has been a positive engagement of the jaws. Unhooking is even easier. My friend has a Curt Q24 in his Ram 3500 SRW and while it has always worked (eventually), he has had a few more issues with his. Typically his issues are with getting the jaws to lock and unlock. It can take some finagling at times to get it to work properly. For me.... I'll hang onto the B&W. It's been a breeze. |
Posted By: alexleblanc
on 08/22/17 12:35pm
|
another B&W fan here - looked at the Curt product and in my mind the only reason most would buy it would be to save money, doesn't look like a quality product IMO.
TV - 2017 F350 CCSB SRW Platinum 6.7 + 5er - 2021 Grand Design Reflection 311 BHS + B&W Companion On Order - 2022 F350 CCSB SRW Platinum 6.7 ![]() |
Posted By: Big1
on 08/23/17 03:04am
|
I have the B&W slider and it seem to be solid but then again this is my first 5th Wheel hitch and the one thing that I like that I have a ball turnover that I can use as a gooseneck.
2022 Ram Laramie 3500 6.7L CTD CCLB 2019 Jayco Eagle 321RSTS |
Posted By: JeffPhillips
on 08/23/17 07:33am
|
I have a 2017 F350 4x4 and pull a Jayco Pinnacle with a MORryde pin box. Curt says the problem is they are both set in rubber and they are fighting each other when hooking up. I am also getting some chucking too. To those that see I have just used it 4 times I have owned two other fifth wheels but had a Reese hitch and never had problems like this. * This post was edited 08/23/17 03:00pm by an administrator/moderator * |
Posted By: waltbennett
on 08/23/17 08:10am
|
B.O. Plenty wrote: ![]() Curt uses foreign made parts assembled in the U.S. Decent unit a little hard to operate at times. B&W is all made in America with all American raw materials. Easiest hitch I have ever hitched or unhitched. Very smooth, positive operation. Shop online and there isn't much price difference. You will get what you pay for. B.O. "Foreign parts"?? Don't know where you got that from! I've had a Q20 for five years now and towed our Montana with it for over 45k miles - we're now in Oregon and heading back east on our fourth trip of over two months each. Never had any issues with the hitch and it's only refused to operate once - my fault for trying to connect when off camber and at a severe angle. I really believe hitch choice is up to the individual. Get which ever one you feel you can operate in your truck the easiest. They all work well if you keep them greased and clean. '06 F350 TD, Softopper, airbags, AeroShield, coolant filter '10 3665RE Hickory edition, wetbolts, Firestone LTs, Trimetric Battery Monitor, 4x100w panels & Morningstar TS-45, still tweeking. |
Posted By: Cummins12V98
on 08/23/17 09:12am
|
""Foreign parts"?? Don't know where you got that from!" Call CURT if you want or just look at your hitch. It is "Made in China" plain and simple. Curt makes many other products in USA (I own a couple) but their 5er hitches are ALL Made in China. |
Posted By: MFL
on 08/23/17 11:31am
|
JeffPhillips wrote: ![]() I have a 2017 F350 4x4 and pull a Jayco Pinnacle with a MORryde pin box. Curt says the problem is they are both set in rubber and they are fighting each other when hooking up. I am also getting some chucking too. To those that see I have just used it 4 times I have owned two other fifth wheels but had a Reese hitch and never had problems like this. Jeff...you've got the best truck, and a really nice FW! I'd sell that Q24 on e-bay, wherever. The Q24 is a popular hitch, should bring a good price. Now get the 3300, and enjoy the ease of hooking/unhooking! The quality build, ease of operation, and great customer service, is what makes B&W fanboys. Oh, the 3300 is lightweight too. Jerry * This post was edited 08/23/17 03:01pm by an administrator/moderator * |
Posted By: fj12ryder
on 08/23/17 03:24pm
|
I'm very happy with my B&W hitch, and have been for the past 10 years.
Howard and Peggy "Don't Panic" |
Posted By: NC Hauler
on 08/23/17 05:48pm
|
B&W 3600 on my truck, love it.. hitches and unhitches with no issues and I've never experienced any chucking. Mine fits in the puck system. Jim * This post was edited 08/24/17 09:27am by NC Hauler * Jim & Kathy, (Boxers, Buddy & Sheba) 2016 Ram 3500 DRW Longhorn 4X4/CC/LB/Aisin/4.10/rear air assist ...Pearl White. 2016 DRV MS 36RSSB3/ W&D/ slide toppers/ DTV satellite/ 5.5K Onan propane gen. B&W RVK3600 Hitch Fulltiming in WV & TX USAF 71-75 Viet Nam Vet |
Posted By: 4x4ord
on 08/23/17 07:20pm
|
tinner12002 wrote: ![]() Showme 5vr wrote: ![]() No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it! X2 x3 2023 F350 SRW Platinum short box 4x4. B&W Companion 2008 Citation Platinum XL 34.5 |
Posted By: mudmaker
on 08/24/17 06:26am
|
JeffPhillips wrote: ![]() I have a 2017 F350 4x4 and pull a Jayco Pinnacle with a MORryde pin box. Curt says the problem is they are both set in rubber and they are fighting each other when hooking up. I am also getting some chucking too. To those that see I have just used it 4 times I have owned two other fifth wheels but had a Reese hitch and never had problems like this. The head of the B&W is set on rubber pads as well. My last camper I had a Morryde hitch too and never experienced any chucking. Glen and Loretta Marc, Jake, Kirsten and fur kids Dexter and Bernie 2017 KZ Venom 4114TK Toy Hauler 2015 GMC Acadia 15 Silverado 3500 SRW quad 6.6 Duramax 11 Silverado 3500 SRW quad 6.6 Duramax |
Posted By: JeffPhillips
on 08/24/17 10:22am
|
Thanks for that reply mudmaker. That does not help Curts explanation for the problems much.
|
Posted By: Travlingman
on 08/24/17 11:27am
|
JeffPhillips wrote: ![]() I have a 2017 F350 4x4 and pull a Jayco Pinnacle with a MORryde pin box. Curt says the problem is they are both set in rubber and they are fighting each other when hooking up. I am also getting some chucking too. To those that see I have just used it 4 times I have owned two other fifth wheels but had a Reese hitch and never had problems like this. I have a 2017 Ford F350 too, along with a MorRyde pinbox on my 5er with a Curt Q25 and have no issues with it. No issues hitching and have a very good ride when pulling rig. |
Posted By: nscaler2
on 08/24/17 01:46pm
|
tinner12002 wrote: ![]() Showme 5vr wrote: ![]() No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it! X2 X3 I'm very happy with my B&W hitch, and have been for the past 11 years. I like the fact that they are totally American made. Needed new U bolts (my fault) they sent me new ones no charge. Actually talked to a real human English speaking person on the phone. Customer service A+++. * This post was edited 08/24/17 01:59pm by nscaler2 * Vanleigh Vilano 325RL w/Mor/ryde pin box Mor/Ryde IS suspension with hydraulic disk brakes and never lube bearings Goodyer G rated tires 2011 GMC 3500HD CC Lb B&W turnover w/Companion |
Posted By: laknox
on 08/24/17 02:41pm
|
nscaler2 wrote: ![]() tinner12002 wrote: ![]() Showme 5vr wrote: ![]() No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it! X2 X3 I'm very happy with my B&W hitch, and have been for the past 11 years. I like the fact that they are totally American made. Needed new U bolts (my fault) they sent me new ones no charge. Actually talked to a real human English speaking person on the phone. Customer service A+++. You're going to need new u-bolts about every 7-8 times you remove your hitch. Those d@mn nylock nuts eventually bind up and you have to just twist them off. (Be sure you have a breaker bar handy!) I've got 2 sets of new bolts on the shelf, but I keep any old ones I feel I could get 1 or 2 more uses out of. Frankly, I should just toss the old nylock nuts and buy new ones and that would give me another 2 sets of u-bolts. :-) Lyle |
Posted By: Ford Man
on 08/25/17 12:11pm
|
B&W
|
Posted By: RCMAN46
on 08/25/17 03:24pm
|
laknox wrote: ![]() RCMAN46 wrote: ![]() I do not believe I have seen a Curt do this. ![]() In a rollover, all bets are off. Lyle There was no rollover. It was a simple case of an evasive maneuver and the head of the B&W disconnected and was snagged on the truck bed which caused the trailer to land on it's side. |
Posted By: fj12ryder
on 08/25/17 03:57pm
|
RCMAN46 wrote: That seems to be at odds from what I read. Which was the trailer started to roll over taking the truck with it. The hitch released which kept the truck from going on over. ![]() There was no rollover. It was a simple case of an evasive maneuver and the head of the B&W disconnected and was snagged on the truck bed which caused the trailer to land on it's side. But perhaps you were there and saw the whole thing? * This post was edited 08/27/17 08:37am by an administrator/moderator * |
Posted By: Cummins12V98
on 08/26/17 06:31pm
|
As President of the "B&W HeavyWeight FanBoy Club" I can attest NOTHING in this world is perfect but the B&W is about as close to PERFECTION as it gets! ![]() |
Posted By: Bigg Al
on 08/26/17 08:53pm
|
fj12ryder wrote: ![]() That seems to be at odds from what I read. Which was the trailer started to roll over taking the truck with it. The hitch released which kept the truck from going on over. But perhaps you were there and saw the whole thing? I think RCMANS explanation makes more sense than yours does, FJ. Why was the trailer rolling over if it was still hitched to the truck which wasn't rolling over? An extreme evasive maneuver makes more sense for why the hitch broke and the trailer ended up on its side. It's amazing how much product loyalty is used to skew the opinion of others even though there is no reward for that loyalty. Curt or B&W, to each his own. * This post was edited 08/27/17 08:38am by an administrator/moderator * Tow Vehicle: 2017 Ram 3500 4x4 DRW Laramie Crew Cab 6.7 Cummins Diesel Race Car: Pro Mod 1969 Chevelle Jerry Bickel Chassis 525ci BAE Hemi Twin Turbocharged 3 Speed Lenco Transmission Best E.T. 5.62 seconds at 265 mph Take me to your Golf Course!! |
Posted By: fj12ryder
on 08/26/17 09:23pm
|
Bigg Al wrote: Have you actually gone and read the account of what happened? The driver performed two severe swerves to avoid traffic and he lost control of the truck/trailer and it started to roll over, both truck and trailer.![]() I think RCMANS explanation makes more sense than yours does, FJ. Why was the trailer rolling over if it was still hitched to the truck which wasn't rolling over? An extreme evasive maneuver makes more sense for why the hitch broke and the trailer ended up on its side. It's amazing how much product loyalty is used to skew the opinion of others even though there is no reward for that loyalty. Curt or B&W, to each his own. Read the account and maybe you'll have a better understanding of what happened. |
Posted By: Madfun119
on 08/31/17 06:34pm
|
Got it folks. Ordered the B&W right after Harvey. Should be in any day now.
|
Posted By: Doughboy12
on 08/31/17 08:22pm
|
laknox wrote: ![]() nscaler2 wrote: ![]() tinner12002 wrote: ![]() Showme 5vr wrote: ![]() No experience with Curt but I do have a B&W, would not trade it! X2 X3 I'm very happy with my B&W hitch, and have been for the past 11 years. I like the fact that they are totally American made. Needed new U bolts (my fault) they sent me new ones no charge. Actually talked to a real human English speaking person on the phone. Customer service A+++. You're going to need new u-bolts about every 7-8 times you remove your hitch. Those d@mn nylock nuts eventually bind up and you have to just twist them off. (Be sure you have a breaker bar handy!) I've got 2 sets of new bolts on the shelf, but I keep any old ones I feel I could get 1 or 2 more uses out of. Frankly, I should just toss the old nylock nuts and buy new ones and that would give me another 2 sets of u-bolts. :-) Lyle Wait What? You should almost never "need" new u-bolts. Nylocks on the other hand are a one time use item that people reuse with good results all the time. ![]() |
Posted By: fj12ryder
on 08/31/17 08:59pm
|
Good choice, it's an excellent hitch.
|
Posted By: spud1957
on 09/01/17 08:07am
|
Yeah, great choice. I would have done the same.
|
Posted By: oakmandan
on 09/10/17 09:01pm
|
I have a B&W. American made in Kansas!
Dan and Diann Hank the Havanese 2019 Grand Design Reflection 320MKS 2015 Ford F-250 FX-4 6.2 Gas MORryde Step Above Steps MORryde Pin Box ![]() |
Print | Close |